Phonon-Polariton lasers

One interesting aspect of semiconductor lasers operating in the THz regime, is that the energy scales of many processes become similar, and therefore non-trivial phenomena mixing these processes occur. For example, both the photon and the longitudinal optical vibrational frequencies (called optical phonons) lie in the THz range. In the normal situation, the laser photon frequency is kept well below the transverse optical (TO) phonon frequency, since these vibrational states strongly absorb radiation close to resonance. On the other hand, when the photon frequency comes close to the TO phonon frequency, there is a constant energy exchange between the vibrational (phonon) and optical (photon) polarization fields which co-exist in the crystal. Due to this strong coupling, they behave as a new massive “quasi”-particle, called a phonon-polariton. Also the electronic intersubband transition, being at the same energy as the laser photons, contribute to this energy exchange, and we have the tri-partite situation depicted in Fig. 1. Since the interaction between the electrons and the polarization modes is in the weak coupling regime, we can treat the interaction of the intersubband system and the strongly coupled phonon-polariton with perturbation theory. We think of this system as similar to the laser system, except that the electrons do not emit photons by stimulated emission, but instead phonon-polaritons. At the edge of the crystal forming the device, the phonons are completely reflected, while the photons are partially transmitted, and can be detected outside of the laser cavity.

Figure 1
Figure 1: The tri-partite coupling, allowing for stimulated emission of phonon-polaritons from intersubband transitions.

Theoretical model

To describe this phenomenon and investigate ways to exploit it, we have developed a model for simulating the phonon polariton gain in a semiconductor heterostructure with population inversion, such as a quantum cascade laser (QCL) or resonant tunneling diode (RTD), shown in Fig. 2. [1]
 

Enlarged view: Figure 2
Figure 2: Quantum cascade laser (left) and resonant tunneling diode (right) designs for phonon-polariton lasers. The resonant phonon mode is confined to the InAlAs barrier.

In these structures, the TO phonons which are in resonance with the laser transition are the AlAs-like phonon modes of the thin InAlAs barriers. Due to the strong light-phonon coupling, the straight photon dispersion line and the (amost) flat phonon dispersion line anti-cross at the resonant frequency and form two distinct polariton branches, as shown by thick purble lines in Fig. 3(a). The two branches are called “upper” (UP) and “lower” (LP) polariton branches, respectively. When going along the wave vector axis inside a particular polariton branch, the nature of the polariton alters between light-like to phonon-like at the two extremes, which is quantified by the Hopfield coefficients hl and hp.  

Enlarged view: Figure 3
Figure 3: (a) Polariton branches and Hopfield coefficients (fraction of phonon resp. photon parts) and (b) gain rate of phonon-polaritons in the QCL design.

In Fig. 3(b) we instead focus on the energy axis in the UP branch, and model the gain rate of phonon polaritons for varying energy (right axis). We see that, over a large energy range it is possible to achieve a larger gain than the total loss (taking into account both phonon and photon losses). We also pay attention to the fraction of the gain coming from the phonon and photon parts, respectively (left axis). We note that while the gain rate is mostly originating from the photon part at high energy where the polariton is mostly photon-like, the gain close to the polariton gap (opening up for energies < 46 meV) is dominated by the phonon part for a short energy range. At the peak of the total gain rate, however, there is still a few percent non-photonic contribution. For this particular structure and emission frequency, the phonon loss rate (originating from decay into acoustic phonons) is actually lower than the photon one, and thus the laser operation is helped by the strong coupling to the phonons.

Experimental studies

We have realized phonon-polariton lasers experimentally [2], shown in Fig. 4. In this design all barriers contain AlAs TO phonons. In order to measure the emitted phonon-polaritons, both the optical spectrum emitted from the laser, and the back-scattered Raman spectrum originating from excited phonon modes, has been measured. Fig. 5(a) shows the Raman spectra when the laser is below respectively above threshold. The narrow, tall peaks of equal height appearing at the expected phonon-polariton frequency above threshold, indicates that phonon-polaritons are coherently generated by stimulated emission in very large numbers. The optical spectrum features peaks at the same frequency, and both optical and phonon spectra show the same threshold behavior, as seen in Fig. 5(b). By tuning the frequency over a broad range for several devices with slight variations in designed emission frequency, we could deduce the group refractive index and match it to the calculated phonon-polariton dispersion as shown in Fig. 6.
 

Enlarged view: Figure 4
Figure 4: SEM picture (A), phonon polariton energy density (B), and (C) design of a quantum cascade phonon-polariton laser.
Enlarged view: Figure 5
Figure 5: (A) Raman scattering spectra below and above threshold showing the emergence of a stimulated emission peak at the phonon-polariton (PP) energy. (B) Laser threshold for the PP laser and a reference device, with no TO AlAs phonons.
Enlarged view: Figure 6
Figure 6 (A) Group index dispersion for the PP and reference devices. (B) Calculated PP dispersion and (C) computed Hopfield coefficients with experimental points inserted.

References

[1] M. Franckié, C. Ndebeka-Bandou, K. Ohtani, and J. Faist, “Quantum model of gain in phonon-polariton lasers,” Phys. Rev. B, vol. 97, no. 7, p. 075402, Feb. 2018, external page DOI.
[2] K. Ohtani et al., “An electrically pumped phonon-polariton laser,” Accept. Publ. Sci. Adv., Apr. 2019, external page DOI.

 

JavaScript has been disabled in your browser